Page 20 of 24

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 31 May 2019, 19:16
by HerzogGorky
Didn't play for 2 weeks or so, played 3 games, 1 of them is bugged ofc
replay id:
#9727253
Won game, lost 11 rating

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 23 Jun 2019, 13:44
by Bohne
Hi guys,

played 4vs4, won the game but loose points....
Replay ID:
#9826281


best regards, Bohne.

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 02 Jul 2019, 16:04
by FlyToha
Hi commanders!

Played 6vs6 on Dual Gap, won the game but loose points....
Replay ID:
#9866511


best regards, FlyToha.

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 06 Jul 2019, 19:36
by particle
Hi FAF team!

Played 6vs6 on Dual Gap, won the game but lost points.
Rating from 942? -> 934

Replay ID:
#9885908

Our team lost 2 com early on to mid, and we fought hard to recover and won the game.
So sad to see after winning, rating drops when I had 2 kills.

Is anyone looking into this?

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 21 Jul 2019, 17:19
by RuthlessNoob
My team won the game and the biggest amount of points went to the guy who did nothing and was sniped early in the game.
Replay #9954458 .

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 21 Jul 2019, 23:52
by FtXCommando
In game performance, barring whether you won/tied/lost, is irrelevant to your, or anyone else’s, individual trueskill change.

https://wiki.faforever.com/index.php?ti ... kill_works

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 31 Jul 2019, 01:20
by SYSTEM_FAILURE
I need to report an issue where the team that won the game all lost points, and the team that lost won points.

Replay ID#9998778
http://content.faforever.com/faf/vault/ ... id=9998778
Replay does not Desync (thankfully)

I would like to request a correction of the points allocated.

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 01 Aug 2019, 22:50
by r1c0ch3t
Played 4vs4 on Astro Crater, won the game but lost points.
Replay ID:
#10009214

My team lost 3 comms and I was the last one standing 1v2. Dunno if it is important but after my team died they were watching the game until one of them alt-f4ed and had to be ejected.

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 02 Aug 2019, 01:00
by Brutus5000
SYSTEM_FAILURE wrote:I would like to request a correction of the points allocated.


I asked one our lobby server devs to look into this.

However, please note that we will not and can not fix rating points - ever. Even if there is a confirmed and fixed bug. The newly calculated rating for all players is affecting all following games, where any of the players of this game participated and that affects all following games where any of the players of these games participant and so on. Basically, the whole rating system would be needed to be recalculated for all games since the fix - a problem with exponential complexity. This is technically never going to happen.

Please also remember that your rating is not a trophy that you are supposed to keep as high as possible. It is a tool to achieve balanced games and even if there is a bug it will adjust itself over the next games again.

Re: Bad rating change from a game? Report here

PostPosted: 02 Aug 2019, 01:38
by Katharsas
SYSTEM_FAILURE wrote:I need to report an issue where the team that won the game all lost points, and the team that lost won points.

Replay ID#9998778
http://content.faforever.com/faf/vault/ ... id=9998778
Replay does not Desync (thankfully)

I would like to request a correction of the points allocated.


Did all 8 players of your game play together in another game shortly after this one?
Edit: We may have found the cause: https://github.com/FAForever/server/issues/485