Proxy Logs

[Deering]

Testing with Nombringer

Logs of a proxy connection and stun server connection.

[Nombringer]

Testing with Deering:

forever.log

(141.93 KiB) Downloaded 82 times

faffityfaf.jpg (169.35 KiB) Viewed 2836 times

[rootbeer23]

Deering-NAT <-> Deering-NAT would/should work.
Nombringer-NAT can only connect to fully forwarded ports.
Deering-NAT <-> fully forwarded would work too of course.

--> you 2 are out of luck with each other. its not FAF's fault.

i guess there will be an alternative proxy in the southern hemisphere at some point.
But that requires some extra coding (to choose the best proxy you have to measure
ping to all proxies). So dont hold your breath. unless you need only 4 liters of O2
for a couple of ... weeks? ... month?...

[Deering]

So i can connect to people with forwarded ports? Ill see if i can get some more tests for the cases where its proxying and shouldn't

[rootbeer23]

the command isnt correct. my bad. please use:

stunclient -m full -v 2 --localport GAME_PORT stun.ekiga.net

game port must be what you have configured in the lobby.

reports with stunclient output are better than those without.
if the 'Nat behaviour' and 'Nat filtering' lines do not change when running stunclient,
then you can omit that. i wouldn't expect any change over time there anyway,
unless the ISP changed their hardware/software.

[Deering]

New stun test

[Nombringer]

New Test:

faffitty v2.jpg (188.35 KiB) Viewed 2748 times

[Deering]

So been playing around with noms computer this afternoon. Port forwarding him did nothing but when we removed that and set upnp in faf it started connecting without the proxy. So here are forever.logs of the connection with no proxy if they can help at all. (I am using port forwarding)

No idea what the difference between port forwarding and upnp is to make this work.

[Nombringer]

Logs:

http://pastebin.com/has2iCwc


I leave the explanation to Deering because I'm lazy. but right now I feel like this dog:

97VP.jpg (63.7 KiB) Viewed 2729 times

[josephbridges]

Nombringer, i did told you about upnp on faf chat.
I bet you 5€, that your AV with firewall/windows firewall f**** has something to do with it.
an app Upnp request most times trigers the right stuff on software/hardware

not to mention that most people set port forwared without reserving the computer IP, so, computer changes IP, port forward makes sh***.

happy to see that it works