I think possibly an opt-in option might be necessary eventually around either an expanded map pool or (more likely) the 5km maps, depending on how the rage builds as 700-1200s (maybe others?) start to realise they're not getting they're favourite maps because they're no longer in the pool.
Add
at least three 5km maps soon for the good of the casual ladder players, some good options IMO:
Esgaroth Ruins,
Crimson Feud,
Blasted Rock (I should really hate this map but I just don't
and I've had some great games on it),
Canis River,
Desert Arena, and
maybe Summer Duel (still kinda rush/draw bait, but I've had/seen a lot of intense matches on it and if you use the secondary fronts you can get an advantage), or
maybe Sentry Point (similar to Summer Duel, it shouldn't play like draw bait given the expansions in the south, but unfortunately does due to the close spawns, so maybe not).
Some bad ones:
Finns Revenge (technically a 10km, but played on half the map so plays like a 5km 99% of the time and awful ACU-in-water-cheese and/or hoverspam OP 95% of the time),
Ambush Pass,
Monaki,
Crag Dunes (all are first bomber bait due to obstacles in the middle for land, but not air),
Winter Duel (more draws than strategic decisions, hellnaw),
Balvery Mountains (slightly better than Winter Duel for draws but the mountain range helps first bomber a lot), and
Desert Joust (slight first-bomber bait, also silly amounts of game-deciding central reclaim).
I think first bomber should be viable, which it is on basically all 5km maps, but not borderline uncounterable when someone's well-practiced at it. Bear in mind it trolls people and they stop playing ladder, so it doesn't need any encouragement.
If this post reads like a negative, my bad:
great work TA, this will make ladder players better at the game, have more close matches and reduces rage-inducing moments on spawn in for people like me
. I'm sure I'm going to search ladder more now. It's better to have a smaller pool so people don't get owned based on map (in)experience. I've found I actually have better luck beating pros/better players on popular maps, because I know how to play them too and can get underestimated. So a smaller pool should also be a positive for lower ranked players - it's not just a "pro" move. Keep being responsive to people's problems for the next little while, which it looks like you will do given you are likely to re-add some decent 5km maps.
In the future I would love to see Cobalt Valley, Syrtis Major, Badlands, Loki in the next core group when you do rotate it. Also, Niflheim is pretty seriously imbalanced in favour of top spawn unfortunately, a mapper should fix it because it SHOULD be good. I'm also not a fan of Sera Outpost (sorry speed, it's the jamming, but I really do appreciate the work you put in) or EOTS (it's MUCH more hated than any of the maps I just listed that I'd like to see in the next core pool).
I hope Seton's Clutch (central reclaim, people hate it), Open Waters (comrush/hoverspam OP) or any of the 5km maps I listed don't get anywhere near the map pool.
Also I just asked Sheeo in #aeolus -
map selection doesn't work anymore for those of you (like me) who were wondering. Personally, I'd like to give people one or two vetoes.