by Zock » 22 Jul 2015, 22:23
It would be nice if you can have the old system as opt-in. So if two people meet who like to play more maps, they can play them and don't have to stop playing ladder because they would only get maps they dislike every game (only half of the time against everyone who does not opt-in for it) Or have similar advanced systems that allows more people to play ladder. Many people will stop now because they don't like the maps. (No matter which maps you choose)
That way you can also see how many people really prefer many maps, and how many don't.
For map rotation itself, i like the core and rotation map system, but i would still replace (some of) the core maps eventually, just not every few weeks like the rotation maps, rather every few months, to keep some consistency but not let it become stale either.
The pool is also heavy baised towards 10x10, which i personally like, but i think it would be fair to add at at 1-2 more 5x5 maps and make sure that with the weekly exchange there are at least 2-3 20x20 maps in the pool. Since many people do not like 20x20 at all (also for time reasons), it might also be a good idea to allow them to opt-out to not play them. Or implement a veto system that allows this. (And if you opt-in for the bigger map pool, you get more vetos in return..)
I'd like to see some statistics about the number of ladder players before and after this change in a few weeks..
Last edited by
Zock on 22 Jul 2015, 22:25, edited 1 time in total.