Forged Alliance Forever

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2016-02-28T07:47:17+02:00

As you can't reliably control the pathing of numerous ships it is often essential that they be stationary to attack targets properly (Summit has to get broadside to target for instance). When the ships are stationary multiple cruisers easily defeat the TMD of the ships to hit the target. The missiles are dumbfire, they don't track. I've had opponents move their ships constantly to avoid that, but that can be made to work against them as their fire effectiveness is reduced in motion (won't all target same ship).

The current balance on this is fine as I see it.

Someone mentioned the idea of putting a T2 engy on a destroyer. Funny you should mention that, I had that idea a while ago, was trying to implement it on the Shield Boat (since it doesn't repair itself, can't rank I was looking to add drones), but I was unable to make a working mod on it. The author of BrewLAN made a working version of what I was looking to do, as a T3 repair/support ship (called Patch) currently UEF only in his mod (downloadable on github). Having a repair ship is a needed feature, it fits with real naval force logistics and then you have something that can move with your ships, instead of engineers that are too slow.

Statistics: Posted by Saxxon — 28 Feb 2016, 07:47

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2016-02-11T22:28:39+02:00

I will throw in my two cents to say that the battleship tmd was very useful to my enemy in a recent game where I went Billy nuke. It made for an interesting mini game of timing the Billy to my cruisers middle barrages in order to distract the tmd.

Statistics: Posted by Tylosaur — 11 Feb 2016, 22:28

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2016-01-30T20:17:41+02:00

There are Ship´s with MML and so there are Ship´s with TMD. --> Logical and necessary.

In gerneral most Vanilla relics are good because Chris Taylore invented them.

Statistics: Posted by MrSprengmeister — 30 Jan 2016, 20:17

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2016-01-30T17:02:23+02:00

Speaking of a relic from Vanilla that's not here anymore - Aeon Strat Bomber TMD Flares lol

Statistics: Posted by snuffles — 30 Jan 2016, 17:02

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-12-06T07:20:45+02:00

Also it just looks really cool. Most of your missiles from the cruisers are still going to hit but damn those ships shooting missiles out of the sky while returning volleys of fire has convinced at least one of my friends to buy the game and play on FAF.

Statistics: Posted by Epson — 06 Dec 2015, 07:20

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-30T02:21:06+02:00

Necessary

Statistics: Posted by yeager — 30 Nov 2015, 02:21

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T23:30:57+02:00

Necessary.

Most "relics" from Vanilla have stayed because they are important...

Statistics: Posted by briang — 29 Nov 2015, 23:30

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T21:25:19+02:00

I think it would only really work if we gave destroyers T2 engie suit, to counter billy.

Statistics: Posted by Rudolph'sRedNose — 29 Nov 2015, 21:25

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T21:22:49+02:00

TMD´s are buildable on water you know...

Statistics: Posted by mirroredwang — 29 Nov 2015, 21:22

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T21:12:41+02:00

Necessary.

Statistics: Posted by JaggedAppliance — 29 Nov 2015, 21:12

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T21:04:58+02:00

Billy. GG.

Statistics: Posted by Rudolph'sRedNose — 29 Nov 2015, 21:04

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T20:57:10+02:00

Zeldafanboy wrote:
if the ships are sitting still

Thats my point. Punishing mistakes-

Statistics: Posted by mirroredwang — 29 Nov 2015, 20:57

Re: TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T20:47:43+02:00

Cruiser and Nuke sub TML has such a high rate of fire that it would break through all but the densest clumps of TMD if the ships are sitting still

Statistics: Posted by Zeldafanboy — 29 Nov 2015, 20:47

TMD on ships - Necessary or relic from Vanilla?

2015-11-29T20:42:34+02:00

I know, people dont like noskillnoskopTML on mexes, but shouldnt we be rewarded for successful cruiser snipes for example?

Statistics: Posted by mirroredwang — 29 Nov 2015, 20:42